England’s young star Jacob Bethell suffered a hamstring injury during the first ODI against India, putting his Champions Trophy 2025 participation in doubt. The 21-year-old all-rounder, known for his batting flexibility and left-arm spin, may miss the tournament in Pakistan, leaving England scrambling for replacements. This setback challenges England’s squad balance ahead of their crucial opener against Australia on February 22.
- Tom Banton, Will Jacks, and Sam Curran are top candidates to replace Bethell.
- Bethell’s absence weakens England’s left-handed batting and spin options.
- England must finalize their 15-player squad by February 12.
Tom Banton: The Front-Runner for Bethell’s Spot
Tom Banton has been called up for the third ODI against India, marking his return after three years. His recent form in the International League T20 (ILT20), where he scored 493 runs in 11 matches, makes him a strong contender. Banton’s aggressive batting style suits Pakistan’s flat pitches, though he lacks Bethell’s all-round skills.
| Banton’s Recent Stats |
|---|
| ILT20 2025: 493 runs, 2 centuries, strike rate 151.69 |
| List A Career: 658 runs, 2 hundreds |
| ODI Experience: 6 matches, 1 fifty |
Banton’s recall highlights England’s trust in his revival after inconsistent past performances. While primarily a top-order batter, his wicketkeeping skills add depth. However, critics argue he isn’t a like-for-like swap for Bethell.
Will Jacks: A Versatile Replacement Option
Will Jacks offers explosive batting and part-time spin, traits England desperately need. Despite falling out of favor recently, his T20 franchise success and ODI strike rate of 100.64 keep him in contention. Jacks’ ability to accelerate in middle overs could fill Bethell’s role as a finisher.
Why Jacks fits:
- Power-hitter: Ideal for high-scoring Champions Trophy games.
- Spin option: Adds variety to England’s bowling attack.
- Experience: 15 ODIs with 4 fifties.
Jacks’ inconsistency in international cricket remains a concern, but his fearless approach aligns with coach Brendon McCullum’s strategy. With Pakistan’s spin-friendly conditions, his off-breaks could prove valuable.
Sam Curran: Adding Balance to the Squad
Sam Curran brings left-arm swing and lower-order hitting, addressing England’s lack of all-rounders. Though overlooked recently, his experience in Asian conditions and ability to bowl during powerplays make him a tactical pick. Curran’s inclusion would ease pressure on England’s frontline bowlers.
| Curran’s Strengths |
|---|
| Bowling: Left-arm variations, economical in death overs. |
| Batting: Aggressive lower-order hitter. |
| Experience: 67 ODIs, 87 wickets. |
Critics question Curran’s pace, but his knack for clutch performances in tournaments like the 2023 World Cup boosts his case. His left-handed batting also diversifies England’s lineup.
England’s Squad Challenges and Champions Trophy Hopes
Losing Bethell weakens England’s left-handed batting and spin depth, critical for Pakistan’s turning tracks. With only three spin options—Adil Rashid, Liam Livingstone, and Joe Root—England risk being outbowled.
Three steps to mitigate Bethell’s absence:
- Prioritize all-rounders like Curran to balance the XI.
- Utilize Banton’s form to strengthen the top order.
- Trust Jacks’ versatility as a backup spinner.
England’s Champions Trophy campaign hinges on adapting quickly. Captain Jos Buttler admitted Bethell’s injury is a “shame” but remains optimistic about replacements stepping up. With Australia as their first opponent, squad cohesion will be tested.
Check out the Champions Trophy Stats
